
Choosing materials for a long lasting roof replacement
Comparing asphalt, metal, tile, slate, and synthetic roofing? Here's how they stack up for lifespan, warranty, weight, looks, and climate fit.


Overall Rating
Based on
6 Categories
We assess roofing contractors using verified customer reviews, service range, responsiveness, workmanship quality, safety practices, and overall value to help you compare options with confidence.

3055 Kettering Blvd #201, Moraine, OH 45439
Division 1 Roofing is a roofing and home exterior company serving Dayton, OH. They provide roof inspections, repairs, and complete roof replacements using high-performance materials from leading manufacturers. Their services also include window, siding, and gutter installation. Division 1 Roofing is BBB accredited and partners with St. Jude Children's Research Hospital, contributing a portion of each job to support its mission. They emphasize thorough roof inspections and timely repairs, especially after storm damage, to protect homes and properties.

5250 N Springboro Pike, Dayton, OH 45449
Van Martin Roofing is a roofing contractor based in Dayton, OH, serving residential and commercial clients in Dayton and nearby communities including Xenia, Springfield, and Huber Heights. With over 20 years of experience, they provide roof replacement, roof repair, gutter and siding installation, and skylight services. The company offers asphalt shingle and metal roofing options, including standing seam metal roofs. Van Martin Roofing also provides free roof inspections and 24-hour emergency repair services to address urgent roofing issues.

5250 N Springboro Pike, Dayton, OH 45439
Van Martin Roofing is a roofing contractor based in Dayton, OH, serving both residential and commercial clients in the Miami Valley area. They offer a wide range of services including roof installation, replacement, repair, leak repair, roof inspections, and certifications. The company also specializes in seamless gutter installations with materials like aluminum and copper, vinyl siding installation, and residential skylight installation. With over 20 years of experience, Van Martin Roofing provides expertise in handling various roof types such as traditional shingles, flat roofs, and metal roofing options like standing seam. Their team is known for managing projects from minor repairs to full roof replacements, and they coordinate closely with insurance companies when needed.

Comparing asphalt, metal, tile, slate, and synthetic roofing? Here's how they stack up for lifespan, warranty, weight, looks, and climate fit.

See the most common early warning signs of roof damage outside and inside your home, and know when it's time to call a roof repair pro.

Learn what to do in the first hours after storm damage - from quick leak control to calling your insurer and an emergency roofer.
Get matched with certified local providers. Takes 30 seconds.