Top Roof Repair in Madison, Wisconsin Ranked

Maintaining a sound roof is a critical part of homeownership in Madison. The city's distinct seasons bring a unique set of challenges for your roofing system, from summer thunderstorms with high winds and hail to the heavy snow and ice dams of winter. Over time, these elements can lead to leaks, damaged shingles, and compromised flashing. Timely roof maintenance and repair is essential to protect your home's interior, structure, and value. This guide provides an overview of common roofing issues, repair processes, and material considerations specific to the Madison area to help you make informed decisions about your home's overhead protection.

The Badger Company

5440 Willow Rd STE 109, Waunakee, WI 53597

The Badger Company is a full-service roofing contractor based in Waunakee, serving Madison, WI, and the broader southern Wisconsin area. They provide residential and commercial roofing installation, replacement, repair, and inspection services, along with siding, gutters, and insulation improvements. The company has experience managing large-scale commercial projects and offers storm damage restoration and insurance claim assistance. One notable capability is their expertise in vented drip edge systems and gutter guard installations, ensuring proper roof ventilation and protection. The Badger Company is known for guiding clients through the insurance claim process and completing projects efficiently.

5.0

250 Reviews

Oliwill Construction

4910 Meinders Rd, McFarland, WI 53558

Oliwill Construction is a roofing contractor based in Madison, WI, offering services for both residential and commercial properties. They specialize in roof installation, roof repair, siding replacement, gutter installation, and window replacement. Their expertise includes metal roofing and standing seam systems, ensuring durable and precise workmanship. Serving Madison and the surrounding communities in South Central Wisconsin, Oliwill Construction focuses on quality materials and craftsmanship to withstand local weather conditions. The company has built a reputation for thorough roof replacements and repairs, as well as comprehensive exterior home improvements.

5.0

186 Reviews

Isthmus Roofing

3007 Kapec Rd, Fitchburg, WI 53719

Isthmus Roofing is a roofing contractor based in Madison, WI, serving the greater Madison metro area and all of Wisconsin. They provide a range of roofing services including roof installation, replacement, repair, leak repair, roof inspections, and certifications. The company is equipped to handle emergency storm damage roof replacements and coordinates with other contractors when needed. Customers have noted their thorough roof inspections and quality installations. Isthmus Roofing has built a reputation for timely and professional service throughout the region.

5.0

174 Reviews

Badgerland Property Service

6662 Lake Rd, Windsor, WI 53598

Badgerland Property Service is a roofing contractor based in Madison, WI, offering residential and commercial roofing installation, replacement, repair, and inspection services. With over 20 years of experience, they specialize in durable roof systems designed to withstand Wisconsin's weather, including storm damage repairs and roof certification. As an Atlas PRO+™ Gold Level Contractor, they provide expert craftsmanship backed by a 10-year workmanship warranty. Founded by veterans, the company emphasizes honest work, trusted materials, and clear pricing without gimmicks.

5.0

121 Reviews

Brookens Construction

6592 Lake Rd # D, Windsor, WI 53598

Brookens Construction is a roofing contractor based in Madison, WI, specializing in residential and multi-family roof repair, replacement, and installation. They serve the Madison, Fox Valley, and Milwaukee areas, focusing on storm and hail damage with expertise in navigating insurance claims. Their services include thorough roof inspections and certifications, backed by a Lifetime Craftsmanship Warranty that ensures repairs and installations comply with Wisconsin building codes. Brookens Construction emphasizes a clear and organized process, from inspection to project completion, with dedicated project management to oversee quality and cleanup.

4.9

979 Reviews

See more providers in Madison, WI

Common Roofing Materials in Madison

The material on your roof dictates its lifespan, repair needs, and overall performance against Wisconsin weather.

• Asphalt Shingles: This is by far the most common roofing material in Madison neighborhoods ¹. They offer an affordable and reliable balance of cost and performance, with a typical lifespan of 15-25 years. Repairs often involve sealing small leaks or replacing individual cracked or missing shingles ².
• Metal Roofing: Gaining popularity for its exceptional durability and longevity, metal roofing can last 40-70 years ³. While the initial installation cost is higher, its resistance to wind, fire, and hail makes it a strong long-term investment for Madison homes. Repair typically focuses on seam integrity and fastener points.
• Wood Shakes and Shingles: Prized for their natural, rustic aesthetic, wood roofs require more maintenance and have a higher associated cost ⁴. They are susceptible to moisture, moss, and decay in Madison's humid climate, so repairs often involve replacing rotten shakes and ensuring proper ventilation to prevent moisture buildup.

What Causes Roof Damage in Madison?

Understanding the primary threats to your roof can help you identify problems early. Madison's climate is a leading factor in roofing deterioration ⁵.

• Severe Weather: High winds can lift and tear shingles, while hail impacts cause granule loss and bruising on asphalt shingles, compromising their waterproofing ^{6 4}. The freeze-thaw cycles of late winter and early spring are notorious for creating ice dams, which can force water back under shingles and into the home ⁷.
• Natural Aging: All roofing materials break down over time. Asphalt shingles become brittle, sealants fail, and metal flashing can corrode. This normal wear and tear makes the roof more vulnerable to the elements ⁸.
• Physical Impact: Falling tree branches during storms or accumulated debris can puncture or crack roofing materials, creating immediate points of water entry.

Typical Roof Repair Procedures

The method of fixing your roof depends entirely on the type and extent of damage discovered during an inspection.

• Shingle Repair: For asphalt roofs, this involves carefully removing damaged shingles and replacing them with new ones to restore the waterproof layer. For minor granule loss or small cracks, a sealant may be applied ^{9 10}.
• Leak Repair: The first and most crucial step is accurately locating the source of the leak, which is not always directly above where water appears inside. Once found, repairs may involve patching the underlayment, replacing damaged decking, and sealing around the leak source ⁸.
• Flashing Repair: Flashing is the metal or rubber material used to seal joints around chimneys, vents, skylights, and in roof valleys. Repair often means resealing with new caulk or, more effectively, replacing sections of corroded or failed flashing ⁶.
• Ice Dam Mitigation: Repairing damage from ice dams involves fixing the interior water damage and replacing compromised shingles and underlayment. Long-term prevention, however, requires improving attic insulation and ventilation to maintain a consistent roof temperature and prevent snow melt ⁷.

What to Expect: Repair Timelines

The duration of a roofing project in Madison depends on the repair's complexity and the weather.

• Minor Repairs: Small jobs like replacing a handful of shingles or sealing a leak around a vent pipe can often be completed in one day or less ¹¹.
• Major Repairs or Full Replacement: Addressing widespread storm damage, structural issues, or a complete roof replacement for an average-sized home typically takes 1-2 days for the core work ¹². However, complications like rotten decking that needs replacement or the need to remove multiple old layers of shingles can extend the timeline.

Understanding Roof Repair Costs in Madison

Costs for roof restoration can vary widely based on the damage's extent, the materials used, and the roof's size and pitch. It's always wise to get multiple detailed estimates.

• Minor Repair (Isolated Shingles or Small Leak): For a simple fix like replacing a few damaged shingles or patching a small, accessible leak, homeowners might expect costs in the range of $150 to $1,000^{6 11}.
• Moderate Repair (Flashing or Vent Boot): Repairs focused on specific components, such as resealing or replacing chimney flashing or a plumbing vent boot, often fall between $200 and $2,000^{8 9}.
• Major Repair (Structural or Extensive Damage): Addressing significant issues like repairing sagging rafters, fixing widespread leak sources, or replacing large sections of decking can range from $1,000 to $6,000 or more⁶.
• Full Roof Replacement: When repairs are no longer cost-effective, a full replacement is needed. For a typical 3,000 sq. ft. home in Madison with asphalt shingles, a complete replacement can cost approximately $14,000 to $20,000+¹². Costs per square foot (a roofing "square" is 100 sq. ft.) vary by material: asphalt shingles average $4-$9, while metal or wood materials can range from $13-$26 per square foot for material and installation ^{1 13}.

The Importance of Professional Inspection

After any major storm or as part of routine seasonal maintenance, a professional inspection is invaluable. A qualified roofer can spot subtle signs of damage-like lifted shingle edges or minor granule loss-that a homeowner might miss. They can also assess the condition of critical components like flashing, vents, and gutters. This proactive approach can identify small issues before they escalate into major, costly interior water damage, saving you money and stress in the long run.

Frequently asked questions

Sources